We Buy Ugly Houses Reviews: Is a Cash Offer Worth It?

We Buy Ugly Houses, also known as HomeVestors, is one of the largest home cash-buying franchises on the market. The company specializes in buying distressed properties for cash, renovating them, and flipping them for profit.

Selling to We Buy Ugly Houses may appeal to homeowners who want to sell quickly and as-is without paying real estate commissions. However, sellers can expect to receive fairly low offers, as franchise owners need to buy low in order to earn a profit when they resell the home at market value.

The company has mostly positive reviews from past customers, with many reviewers praising their local franchise employees' professionalism, as well as the ease and speed of the transaction. Some negative reviews mention inadequate offers and aggressive marketing.

If you’re considering selling your home for cash, it's wise to get at least a few competing offers to make sure you're not leaving any money on the table.

To save time, you can start with an offers marketplace like Clever Offers. This free service brings you competing cash offers from a variety of local and national buyers, so you can compare your options and choose the best deal — without any added fees or pressure to move forward. Simply fill in a few details about your home, review offers without obligation, and sell in as little as 7 days.

What properties are a good fit for HomeVestors?

Like most cash home buyers, We Buy Ugly Houses will purchase almost any type of property — including townhomes, condos, multi-tenant properties, and some mobile homes. This includes houses that would otherwise be difficult to sell due to their condition.

There’s also no need to clean the home or remove unwanted belongings. We Buy Ugly Houses will handle those steps for you, as is typical with cash buyers.

You might consider selling to HomeVestors if:

• The home has liens or title issues. Because these challenges can make it hard for buyers to secure financing, these properties may be more difficult to sell through a traditional transaction.
• Your house needs work, and you don’t want to make repairs. We Buy Ugly Houses buys homes in their current condition, which may include significant issues like water damage, major system concerns, or foundation or roof problems.
• You need a quick sale. If you need to sell your house fast due to a job relocation, divorce, or foreclosure, HomeVestors can close in as little as three weeks.
• You’ve inherited a property you don’t want or need. As a beneficiary, you may not have the time, money, or desire to try to sell the home through an agent.
• You no longer want to maintain a rental property. Whether the house is vacant or occupied, most cash buyers will purchase rental properties you want to offload.

How does We Buy Ugly Houses work?

We Buy Ugly Houses operates on a franchise model. Franchise licensees purchase the rights to use the We Buy Ugly Houses / HomeVestors name and receive mentorship, marketing materials, lead generation tools, market research, and access to a proprietary app for property evaluations.

While each HomeVestors office is independently owned and operated, licensees agree to operate according to standard procedures furnished by the corporate office. The process of selling your house to HomeVestors is fairly typical for the industry. Here's what you can expect:

1. Request a consultation. Sellers initiate the process by submitting an online form or calling their local franchise.
2. Schedule a walkthrough. A franchise representative evaluates the property’s condition and determines whether repairs are necessary.
3. Receive an offer. The seller receives an as-is cash offer, usually within 24-48 hours of the walkthrough.
4. Close quickly. If the offer is accepted, the closing process can be completed in as little as three weeks, though some sellers may find this timeline slower than competitors.

HomeVestors gives sellers a 3-day cancellation period, called the HomeVestors Advantage, allowing them to back out of the sale penalty-free if they change their mind.

What are the costs of selling to We Buy Ugly Houses?

Getting an offer from We Buy Ugly Houses is free, and there are no out-of-pocket costs or commissions. Cash buyers will also typically cover your closing costs by factoring them into the offer amount.

The average cost to sell a house runs about 8–10% of the sale price, including closing costs, agent commissions, and associated costs like cleaning, landscaping, staging, and professional photography. That means that if you sell your home for $400,000, you’ll pay roughly $32,000 to $40,000

Real estate commission fees can range from 5–6% of the sale price if you agree to cover the buyer’s agent fee. In the example above, that could account for about $24,000 in selling costs.

However, the trade-off is that offers from a We Buy Ugly Houses rep will typically be well below market value. House flippers need a substantial discount off the purchase price to make a profit when they resell the home for market value. 

How much does We Buy Ugly Houses pay?

We Buy Ugly Houses doesn't advertise the exact amount or range of cash offers it typically makes to buyers. However, these types of We Buy Houses companies typically start their offers at about 70–75% of a home’s after-repair value (ARV), minus the repair costs. Say your home would be worth $400,000 after about $20,000 in repairs. You could expect to receive an offer of around $260,000.

"This is very common and standard practice among investors," explains Charles H. Chandler III, CEO and Co-Founder of My Tennessee Home Solution. "We determine the resale value of the property, then multiply that resale value by 75%, and then deduct the cost of the renovation to achieve that resale value from its current condition, and that final number gives us our offer amount."

You could get more if your home is in a desirable area. It’s also important to note that the offer quality can vary by franchise location. Some reviewers say they received fair offers, while others were disappointed. One seller, Greg, said a franchise owner told him that $225,000 was the best offer he could get, but the home was later sold for $430,000.

Another factor that could affect your offer: We Buy Ugly Houses encourages wholesaling through its DealVestors platform.[1] This means that rather than purchasing your home outright, the buyer will get you under contract and then assign the contract to another house flipper for more than they're offering you.

Franchise owners are incentivized to make lower offers, increasing the profit potential for them and the end buyer. 

Cash buyers aren’t the only option if you need to sell as-is. An iBuyer like Opendoor may offer more — about 90% of market value — and can close faster. But not all homes will qualify, and you’ll have to pay service fees and repair costs. To sell for the highest possible price, and keep more of the equity, look for an agent offering a competitive commission rate (think 1.5% vs. the typical 3%).

Cash buyer vs. realtor: Estimated net proceeds on a $400,000 house needing $20,000 in repairs

Selling method	Estimated proceeds*
Investor / House flipper (Sold as is, no fees or closing costs)	$260,000
iBuyer (Sold as is, $30,000 condition adjustment, 5% service fee, 1% in closing costs)	$308,400
Full-commission realtor (Sold as is, $20,000 repair concession, 6% toward agent fees, 1% in closing costs)	$353,400
Low commission realtor (Sold as is, $20,000 repair concession, 4% toward agent fees, 1% in closing costs)	$361,000

We Buy Ugly Houses reviews

Source	Average Rating	Review Count
BBB	1.3	27
Google	4.7	2,974
Weighted Average:	4.7	3,001

*We Buy Ugly Houses doesn’t have one dedicated page on Google, and many local franchises are listed under the “We Buy Ugly Houses and HomeVestors” name.

The company has many positive reviews on Google, but Yelp and BBB comments are less flattering. Remember that the customer experience depends largely on their location and the We Buy Ugly Houses franchise they work with.

✅ Positive We Buy Ugly Houses reviews

'Quick and easy'

Many customers praise the ease and speed of the transaction, eliminating the stress of their home sale.

‘Did everything they said they would do’

Reviewers often leave positive feedback on how the We Buy Ugly Houses team handles their transaction. Comments highlight professionalism, compassion, flexibility, and understanding of the seller's circumstances.

❌ Negative We Buy Ugly Houses reviews

'Told me the house needed at least $120,000 worth of work'

Scattered reviews mention low offers and inflated repair costs.

Pros and cons of We Buy Ugly Houses

Is We Buy Ugly Houses reputable?

We Buy Ugly Houses / HomeVestors was founded in Dallas in 1996 and its franchises operate in most major markets throughout the United States. As a whole, the company has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

But in 2023, ProPublica published an investigative report on We Buy Ugly Houses, revealing troubling practices and unethical behavior within its ranks.[2]

The investigation uncovered how some franchisees targeted vulnerable homeowners, such as financially distressed and elderly sellers. The operators allegedly used deceptive practices and valuated homes unreasonably low. If sellers tried to back out of the deal, the franchise owners would threaten to take them to court to push the deal through.

After the report went public, We Buy Ugly Houses implemented changes to its business practices. For example, it revised its training policies and added a three-day window for a seller to back out of a contract and modified parts of franchise owners' training.[3]

However, a separate incident further tested the company's oversight. In 2024, a former top-performing franchise owner named Charles Carrier was accused of running a Ponzi-like scheme through his Dallas-based franchise, C&C Residential Properties. According to ProPublica and federal court documents, Carrier defrauded approximately 80 investors out of nearly $40 million by taking out multiple loans against the same properties and using new investor money to pay off earlier investors.[4] We Buy Ugly Houses reported Carrier to the FBI after receiving a tip through its newly established ethics hotline — created in response to the original ProPublica investigation. The company also revoked Carrier's franchise and later sued him for trademark infringement.

Under current CEO Joshua Waltzer, the company has continued to emphasize its ethics hotline and its code of conduct for franchisees, but oversight gaps may still exist. Apart from these incidents, most HomeVestors locations maintain above-average customer ratings and have a solid track record of ethical dealings.

Cash offer alternatives to We Buy Ugly Houses

We Buy Ugly Houses makes solid cash offers on homes in any condition and has a good reputation with customers online. But the cash buyer isn’t the only one out there, and working with a competitor may better suit your needs.

Sellers who get competing offers tend to have better outcomes. Below are other highly rated cash home buying companies that can also help you close quickly and easily.

🔍 How to vet a cash buyer

• Request proof of funds. A reputable buyer should be able to provide a recent bank statement or a letter from their financial institution showing they have the cash available.
• Check the company's track record. If the buyer is with a company, look up that company’s online reviews, BBB ratings, and past transactions. Established buyers tend to have a visible history you can verify.

🚩 Red flags to watch out for

• No proof of funds. If they can’t or won’t document their ability to pay, they probably don’t have the money.
• High-pressure tactics. Scammers may push you to sign immediately, hoping you won’t have time to compare offers or seek advice.
• Low earnest money. A legitimate investor should be willing to put down at least a 1–2% earnest money deposit. The deposit should be due at signing and become non-refundable after a brief inspection period (less than 10 days). Insignificant deposits ($0–$500), deposits due after the inspection, or deposits that remain refundable up until closing are red flags.
• Vague or incomplete contracts. A legitimate buyer will provide clear, specific terms — including the length of the due diligence period, the amount of earnest money put down, the specific reasons that a contract may be cancelled, and what happens to the earnest money if a contract is cancelled outside of those reasons. Ambiguity often works in the other party’s favor, not yours.
• No reviews or sales history. If you can’t find any instance of the company online or they refuse to provide evidence of past deals, it’s a good idea to walk away.

Compare legitimate offers from a nationwide network or verified cash buyers. It's fast, secure, and free.

We Buy Ugly Houses reviews: The bottom line

We Buy Ugly Houses is a nationwide home buyer that purchases distressed properties for cash as-is. While it offers a hassle-free solution for homeowners, sellers should be aware that they’ll sacrifice some profit for the speed and convenience. What’s more, the quality of service can vary significantly depending on your local franchise.

To make the most out of the sale, try to get offers from a few different buyers and know your property’s real market value before deciding.

💡Want the best possible price from a cash buyer? Clever Offers helps you compare multiple cash offers side by side, so you can pick the highest offer with the best terms for your needs, all in one place and at no cost.

Related reading